Heading	Subheading	Result	4-5 (Good)	3 (Minimum)	1-2 (Insufficient)
Accuracy	Central claims		All Correct		1 or more incorrect
	Supporting Claims		All correct	1 incorrect	2 or more false
	Verifiable		All correct and verifiable	Falsely asserted/unproven/controversial as fact	Common-knowledge counterfactual information
Completeness	Prompt Request Coverage		All explicit asks addressed		Not all explicit asks addressed
	Constraints		All constraints placed addressed		Not all constraints placed addressed
	Breadth of Solutions [STEM]		Multiple possible solutions with in-depth explanation	Multiple possible solutions referred but not explained in-depth	Not show multiple possible options to solve
Relevance	Supporting content		Logically defends key points/central claims	Tangentially related to the central claim	Unrelated to the central claim
	Specificity		Supported with precise/rigorously chosen examples	Contains a few selected examples but doesn't explain/relate them	Examples are vague/overly general
	Usefulness		Each part directly adds value to the claims or context	Mix of useful and irrelevant but not directly useful information within the response	Information provided does not logically contribute to the main claim
Depth	Justification		Indepth information/analysis is provided	Surface-level but helpful (missing analysis)	No supporting information
	Context		All background information provided	Missed minor background information	Not necessary contextual information provided
Conciseness	Repetition		No unnecessarily repeat	Repeats in a slightly different way	Exact same repetition
	Length		As specified	Close to specified	Significantly exceeds
	Verbosity		Concise and perfect response	Some overly verbose sentences	Poor conciseness
Spelling & Grammar	Readability		No spelling/grammatical errors	Some errors but still readable	Multiple errors affecting readability
	Language Mechanics		Advanced	Minor corrections	Incorrections
Formatting and Coherence	Visual Presentation		Visually separated		No visual separation
	Text Formatting		Lists/bolding/Markdown used appropriately		Not appropriately used
	Outline and Coherence		Good outlined ideas with transition in logical order	Outlined but transition between paragraphs should be improved	Not good
Tone Appropriateness	Instruction Following		Voice/persona followed		Antithetical to the explicit instructions
	Audience Appropriate		Diction/attitude appropriate	Doesn't quite capture the ideal intent	Inappropriate
Safety			No Harmful/Illegal/Profanity/Bias/Stereotyping		Have Harmful/Illegal/Profanity/Bias/Stereotyping